The big selling point is the adjustable fill. The Coop comes stuffed with shredded memory foam and microfiber blend, and you can unzip it and remove fill until you get the exact loft and firmness you want. They also include an extra half pound bag of fill in the box so you can add more if you need it.

This matters because most pillows are a gamble. You buy one, its either too thick or too flat, and you’re stuck with it. With the Coop you can literally reach inside, pull out a handful of fill, test it for a night, adjust again. Takes about 3 nights to dial in but once you find your sweet spot, it stays there.

The cover is a bamboo derived rayon and polyester blend thats machine washable. The whole pillow is machine washable actually, which is a bigger deal than it sounds. Most memory foam pillows say “spot clean only” and slowly become gross over time. Being able to throw this in the washer every month or two is a real advantage.

I’m a side sleeper, about 170 lbs, and I ended up removing maybe a third of the fill. Out of the box it was way too thick for me. If you’re a bigger person or a strict back sleeper, you’ll probably keep most of the fill in. The point is you can customize it, which already puts it ahead of 90% of pillows on the market.

Once dialed in, the shredded memory foam conforms to your head and neck without that sinking-into-quicksand feeling you get with solid foam pillows. Theres some bounce to it thanks to the microfiber blend. It doesn’t go completely flat after a few hours the way cheap shredded foam does.

Temperature wise, its noticeably cooler than my old solid memory foam pillow. Not as cool as a dedicated cooling pillow with gel or phase change material, but the shredded fill creates air channels between the pieces that help dissipate heat. I didn’t wake up flipping the pillow to the cool side, which used to happen a lot with my old one.

One complaint I do have: the fill shifts. If I start on my side and roll to my back during the night, I sometimes wake up with a lumpy distribution. Not enough to ruin my sleep, but enough that I notice it in the morning and have to fluff things around. If you sleep like a rock and dont move, this wont be an issue. If you toss and turn a lot, it might bug you.

Side sleepers who havent found the right pillow height yet. The adjustable fill is genuinely the best solution I’ve found for dialing in side sleeper loft without buying five different pillows.

People who run warm. Its not a cooling pillow, but the shredded fill breathes way better than solid foam. If your current pillow turns into a heat trap by 2am, this is a solid upgrade.

Anyone who wants a washable memory foam pillow. This is surprisingly rare. Most foam pillows cant go in the machine. The Coop can, and it holds up well.

Stomach sleepers. Even with most of the fill removed, its still thicker than what most stomach sleepers need. You’d be better off with a flat traditional pillow or something like the ACCURATEX on its thinnest setting.

People who want firm, structured support. The shredded fill is inherently soft and moldable. If you want a pillow that holds its shape like a contoured cervical pillow, look at the Cushion Lab Deep Sleep instead.

Budget shoppers. At $60 to $72, this is a premium pillow. If you’re happy with a $20 to $30 option, theres no reason to spend this much. A good budget alternative is the ACCURATEX adjustable pillow which does a similar thing for about half the price, though the foam quality isnt quite as good.