Streetlights, a partners reading lamp, summer sunrises at 5:40am. Whatever the light source, you have two real options: block the window or block your eyes. People get weirdly loyal to their pick, so heres the honest breakdown of both.
Blackout Curtains
Sleep Mask
| Feature | Blackout Curtains | Sleep Mask |
|---|---|---|
| Darkness level | Very dark, some edge glow | True blackout (good ones) |
| Cost | $25 to $80 per window | $10 to $40 total |
| Works for partners too | Yes, whole room | No, just you |
| Travel | Stays home | Goes anywhere |
| Comfort factor | Nothing on your face | Depends on the mask and how you sleep |
| Bonus effects | Some heat and noise reduction | None |
Blackout Curtains, Pros & Cons
What We Liked
- The whole room gets dark, not just your eyeballs
- Helps keep the room cooler in summer
- Zero adjustment period, nothing to get used to
Worth Knowing
- Light leaks around the edges unless you mount them wide and high
- Costs add up fast with multiple windows
- Youre in full darkness at 8am too, which cuts both ways
Sleep Mask, Pros & Cons
What We Liked
- Cheapest path to total darkness
- Contoured ones dont press on your eyes
- One purchase covers home, hotels, planes, the in-laws guest room
Worth Knowing
- Side sleepers need a contoured or low-profile mask or itll shift off by 2am
- Cheap flat masks leak light at the nose, dont bother with those
Weve compared a bunch of both. The Manta Sleep Mask Pro is the one that made a mask convert out of a lifelong skeptic here, and our blackout sleep masks roundup has cheaper picks too. Going the window route instead? Our blackout curtains buyers guide covers sizing and mounting so you dont get the dreaded edge glow.
The Bottom Line
Get a contoured sleep mask first. Its ten to forty bucks to find out if total darkness fixes your sleep, and most people are surprised how much it does. Add blackout curtains later if the mask keeps sliding off or you share the room and want it dark for both of you. Plenty of light-sensitive sleepers end up with both and use the mask for travel.
Disclosure: Some links in this article are affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.You might also like:
- Best Fans for Sleeping in 2026: 5 Picks Quiet Enough to Leave On All Night
- Best Sleep Products for Couples in 2026
- Back to School Sleep Essentials: 7 Dorm Picks for Better Sleep
Browse all Sleep Environment >
